Mass Production

Mass production is a key issue to EPN commercialization. Identification of potential isolate, characterization of symbiotic bacteria and suitable media are important factors. Axenic culture process for S. glaseri and S. carpocapsae was developed in 1940 followed by an inexpensive medium for C. elegans with high yields. A variety of substances; Potato mash, ground veal pulp, peptone-glucose agar and pork kidney, homogenized animal tissue, dog food, chicken offal homogenate. Modified dog biscuit, egg yolk and soy flour and cholesterol medium were suitable for indigenous isolates.

In the in vivo process, an insect serves as a bio-reactor; in the in vitro process, artificial media are used. For testing in field experiments larger quantities of nematodes are necessary, which are preferably produced near the testing facilities in order to maintain nematode quality. Although H. indica is more resistant to heat stress than H. bacteriophora (Glazer et al., 1996; Shapiro et al., 1996), a decrease in the nematode's control potential due to high temperature during long distance transportation can severely decrease nematode survival and control potential. EPNs possess specific biological and ecological features, which make their use in biological control exceptionally safe. Using the in vivo process, yields between 0.5 x 105 and 4 x 105 IJs/larva, depending on the nematode species, have been obtained (Grewal, et al., 1994 Dutky, et al., 1964., Flanders, et al., 1996).

During the past few years, a distinct cottage industry has emerged that utilizes the in vivo process for nematode mass production for sale, especially in the home lawn and garden markets. However, the in vivo process lacks any economy of scale, the labour, equipment, and material (insect) costs increase as a linear function of production capacity. Perhaps even more important is the lack of improved quality while increasing scale. The in vivo nematode production is increasingly sensitive to biological variations and catastrophes as scale increases. In a scale-up model, Friedman (1990) reported that the solid-culture method is economically feasible up to a production level of approx l0x1012 nematode/mo. Labour costs increase significantly for nematode production beyond this level, making a less expensive method of large-scale production a necessity.

Following recovery from production substrates, the nematodes can be either stored in bulk for extended periods or formulated immediately. When the nematodes are to be stored as bulk, nematode concentration, temperature, aeration, and contamination control are important considerations for the maintenance of high viability and quality. Differences in storage stability among nematode species can be attributed to their thermal and behavioral adaptations. Each nematode species has a well-defined thermal niche (Grewal, et al., 1994) and an optimum temperature for the longest storage stability.

S. feltiae stores better at 50C and S. scapterisci. S. riobrave and H. bacteriophora are more stable at 100°C. S. carpocapsae and S. scapterisci that adopt a quiescent posture during storage generally store better than the more active species, such as H. bacteriophora and S. riobrave. The latter species also tend to be more prone to bacterial contamination during storage. Antimicrobial agents may be used to suppress contamination, and the choice of the antimicrobial should be based on its safety to nematodes and symbiotic bacteria.

EPNs can be mass-produced by in vivo or in vitro methods. In the in vivo process, an insect serves as a bioreactor; in the in vitro process, artificial media are used. The in vivo process is very simple and requires only minimal initial investment. The equipment used is also simple: trays and shelves. The wax moth larvae are most commonly used to rear nematodes because of their commercial availability. The methods of nematode infection, inoculation, and harvesting have been previously described (24-27). Using the in vivo process, yields between 0.5 x 105 and 4 x 105 IJs/larva, depending on the nematode species, have been obtained. During the past few years, a distinct cottage industry has emerged that utilizes the in vivo process for nematode mass production for sale, especially in the home lawn and garden markets. However, the in vivo process lacks any economy of scale; the labor, equipment, and material (insect) costs increase as a linear function of production capacity. Perhaps even more important is the lack of improved quality while increasing scale. The in vivo nematode production is increasingly sensitive to biological variations and catastrophes as scale increases. As early as 1931, Rudolf Glaser recognized the value of developing artificial culture methods for entomopathogenic nematodes, and devised the first such method for S. glaseri. However, Glaser was unaware of the significance of symbiotic bacteria in the nutrition and pathogenicity of nematodes, which was only, recognized much later. Therefore, the first successful commercial-scale monoxenic culture was developed by Bedding, and has come to be known as solid culture. In this method, nematodes are cultured on a crumbed polyether polyurethane sponge impregnated with emulsified beef fat and pig's kidneys, along with symbiotic bacteria. Using this method, approx 6x105-10 x 105 IJ/g of medium were achieved. Since then, this method has been commercially used in Australia, China, and the United States. In a scale-up model, Friedman reported that the solid-culture method is economically feasible up to a production level of approx l0x10-12 nematodes/mo. Labor costs increase significantly for nematode production beyond this level, making a less expensive method of large-scale production a necessity.

Friedman (29) reported the development of a liquid-fermentation technique for large-scale production of nematodes. In this method, costs of production decrease rapidly up to a capacity of approx 50 x 1012 IJs/mo. This method allows consistent production of steinernematids in as large as 80,000-l fermenters. Recent improvements in the nematode fermentation and media formulation processes have resulted in further improvements in nematode quality and yields (P. S. Grewal, unpublished data). The current yields of S. carpocapsae in the liquid culture average about 2.5 x 105 IJs/g. In addition to S. carpocapsae. s. riobravis. S. scapterisci. S. feltiae. S. glaseri. H. bacteriophora and H. megidis have been produced successfully in large-scale liquid cultures.

In vivo culturing of EPN
Entomopathogenic nematodes can be mass produced by in vivo technique, in which the insects serve as small biological reactors. Most of the researchers today use G. mellonella L. for this purpose. Karunakar et al. (1992) reared S. feltiae, S. glaseri and H. bacteriophora on C. sacchariphagus indicus and S. excerptalis. Yields of 1,27,000 (S. feltiae), 3,70,000 (S. glaseri), and 2,10,000 (H. indica) IJs were obtained from fifth instar larvae of C. sachariphagous indicus when introduced @ 20 IJs.

In vitro culturing of EPN
Attempts were made to mass-produce H. indica, H. bacteriophora and S. glaseri on different artificial media at SBI, Coimbatore as per method described by Wouts (1981). Attempts were made to isolate the symbiotic bacteria Photorhabdus and Xenorhabdus spp. from infected insects for developing monoxenic cultures of EPN. About 8,00,000 to 10,00,000 IJs were harvested from a single Bedding conical flask after 25 days (Anon, 2000). In another collaborative project, Ehlers et al. (2000) mass produecd the EPN in solid and liquid media. They found the, highest growth temperature for the bacterial symbiont P. luminescens isolated from H. indica. The nematode type strain LN2 was transferred to monoxenic cultures on its symbiont P. luminescens and was successfully produced on solid media. In liquid cultures, a mean dauer juvenile yield of 4,57,000 per ml was obtained for a total of 61 liquid cultures of the nematode at 250 C, with the highest yield of 6,48,000 per ml. Comparatively high yields have not been reported before. Therefore, costs related to the liquid culture production of H. indica will be lower than for other EPN currently used in biological control. Different bacterial clones had no significant influence on the dauer juvenile yields in liquid media. The exit from the dauer juvenile stage (recovery) after inoculation and the number of hermaphrodites significantly decreased when culture temperature was increased from 25-300 C; the dauer juvenile yields were not affected. The cell density of P. luminescens in batch cultures was higher at 25 and 300 C than at growth temperatures of 35 and 370 C. In continuous culture, the bacterial growth was inhibited when the growth temperature reached 380 C. After approximately 60 h, the bacteria adapted to higher temperature and the growth rate increased again. When the temperature was further increased to 400 C, the bacterial growth was inhibited.

Mass Production

Rudolph Glaser was the first to successfully devise a culture method for an entomopathogenic nematode (Steinernema) on artificial medium (Glaser, 1931). However, Glaser was unaware of the need for the symbiotic bacterium that kills the insect host by septicaemia, supplies nutrients for the nematode, and, produces antibiotics to suppress secondary invaders. The absence of the bacterium resulted in the nematode's failure to become a biological control agent of the Japanese beetle (Gaugler et al., 1992). Subsequent rearing efforts with other EPN species were made primarily with insect hosts (Dutky et al., 1964). This method is still widely (employed in research laboratories and by some in cottage industry. However, in vivo production costs are far too high for large- scale commercial production. A major breakthrough in mass production was made by Bedding (1984) who developed a monoxenic semi-solid culture technique that achieved much higher and more consistent yields. A semi-automated harvesting process further reduced production costs. This technique has been the choice for a number of decentralized societies, such as China, and small commercial operations (Georgis, 1990). In scaled-up production by the Bedding technique, costs fall with increasing scale up to an output level of approximately 10x10 12 infective juveniles/month. Above this point, labour costs become significant. Production by monoxenic liquid fermentation costs less than other methods, and these costs decrease more rapidly up to a capacity of approximately 50x1012infective juveniles/month (Friedman, 1990).

At present S. carpocapsae, S. feltiae, S. glaseri and S. riobravis can be consistently and efficiently produced in 7500-80000 litre fermenters with a yield capacity as high as 150000 infective juveniles/ml (Georgis and Manweiler, 1994). Because of distinct physiological differences among nematode strains and species (Akhurst and Boemare, 1990; Poinar, 1990), the growing medium varies significantly. In general, it contains water, an emulsifier, a yeast source, a vegetable oil and a protein source (Georgis, 1992). Other important considerations for achieving consistently high- quality yields are optimum aeration, shear sensitivity, and the stability of the phase I bacterium and its interaction with the nematode (Friedman, 1990). The bacterium exists in two phases, I and II. Phase I produce antibiotics and supports greater nematode production in vivo and in vitro than phase II (Akhurst and Boemare, 1990).

In vivo:Progeny production evaluated in different lepidopteran insect pests indicated maximum yield in final instar larvae of G. mellonella. H. bacteriophora recorded highest yield in G. mellonella followed by S. litura and H. armigera. H.indica PDBCEN13.3 yielded higher in H. armigera, O. arenosella, P. xylostella and P. operculella compared to H. bacteriophora. S. bicornutum yielded maximum in all the insects followed by S. carpocapsae PDBCEN 11, S. carpocapsae PDBC 6.11, and S. glaseri .Yields of of S. carpocapsae, S. feltiae S. glaseri and H. bacteriophora in A. ipsilon and G. mellonella have been influenced by initial inoculum level. In general the production levels were higher in G. mellonella compared to A. ipsilon increased inoculum levels need not necessarily increase the multiplication of nematodes and optimum level for maximum multiplication depends on nematode isolates and host insects (Hussaini et al., 2008b).

In vitro production:

Steinernematids and heterorhabditids can be cultured monoxenically on a variety of artificial media. The cultures are raised either in flasks or autoclavable bags. The prepared medium is coated in to 1 ml porous polyether polyurethane foam chips, which provide a large surface area for the bacteria to multiply and hence the IJs. It is ensured that pores are still visible holding sufficient medium inside and the medium added to foam come out of the pores if squeezed. Flasks are plugged with non-absorbent cotton and autoclaved. Foam chips with sterilized medium are inoculated with primary phase of bacteria (Xenorhabdus for Steinernema and Photorhabdus for Heterorhabditis). The bacterial cultures are maintained in 5ml of nutrient broth in test tubes for 24 h on a shaker and inoculated on a sterilized medium (one tube per flask) aseptically.

The bacteria and media are mixed well and incubated at 25oC for 3 days to allow the bacterial multiplication. Infective juveniles are surface sterilized and added to flasks at 106 and 107 per flask for steinernematids and heterorhabditids, respectively) to start new cultures. Cultures are established in 2-3 weeks. Incubation of cultures at temp (25°C) is important ,besides proper moisture and maintenance of bacterial purity (streak on to NBTA or MacConkey agar and identify contaminants) concentration, 100,000 IJs/ml, conical flasks with aeration facility are more suitable. Harvest of nematodes is done by taking out foam pieces on to a 20-mesh sieve and placing in a pan of water to submerge the pieces. Infective juveniles migrate to the water, which is collected in a beaker, let it settled down, decanted and more sterile water is added. The process is repeated 2-3 times and stored in tissue culture flasks at a concentration of 10-20 thousands nematodes per ml.

In vitro: Plant and animal protein media were evaluated in vitro for production of indigenous isolates of S. carpocapsae, S. bicornutum and S. tami and one of H. indica. Wout's medium, modified egg yolk, Soyflour + cholesterol and modified dog biscuit yielded highest number of IJs of S. carpocapsae, S. tami and H. indica PDBC EN 6.71. Maximum yield of S. carpocapsae PDBC EN 6.11 and PDBCEN 6.61 IJ was obtained on modified dog biscuit (Hussaini et al., 2000a,2002e). Costs of 10-60% more has been envisaged with use of nematode-based products than with chemical insecticides (Georgis & Hague, 1991) Technological improvements in production, formulation, packaging and shelf life of the products may change the scenario. Since nematode products are safe to apply and do not contaminate the environment, some clients opt for a biological control method even at a higher cost. Also, at least in some situations, the nematodes become established; recycle and their offspring continue to control the target insect. Thus, the higher short-term cost may be lower in the long run when continued control by the recycling nematode is obtained. Thus, by the judicious use of nematodes and chemicals, it may be possible to reduce the cost of control and protect the environment at the same time.

Scale up

In vitro Solid culture: Mass production on artificial media was realized 30 yrs before Dutky et al 1964 established in vivo methods. Solid culture was pioneered by Rudolf Glaser who was the first to artificially culture a parasitic nematodes .Glaser and his co workers in one of the most ambitious and least known experiments in biological control, produced and released billions of S. glaseri throughout New Jersey against Japanese beetles from 1939 to 1942 ( Fleming 1948). Regretably early workers were unaware of the nematode's bacterial partner. Nematode production was carried out in shallow trays of veal pulp medium with salicylic acid and formalin to repress contaminating microbes (Mc Coy and Girth 1938) including apparently the natural symbiont Xenorhabdus poinarii (Gaugler et al 1992 ). Today need for monoxenicity is universally recognized as one of the cornerstones of nematode in vitro culture (Poinar and Thomas 1966). Laboratory: others would extend Glaser's accomplishments by developing alternative media to costly animal tissue homogenates such as dog food medium (House et al 1965) . Regardless of the growth medium cultures were produced on the substrate surface because of the need for gas exchange viz., cultures were two dimensional perfectly suited for lab cultures but a limitation that precluded commercial production Bedding (1981&84) development of practical solid culture technology was a seminal step in nematode production because it leapt from two to three dimensional substrates. Beddings flask cultures involved thinly coating crumbed polyurethane foam sponge with poultry offal homogenate .The porous foam afforded an outstanding area to volume ratio for growth while providing adequate gas exchange .Next advance was to adopt large autoclavable bags to replace flasks.

The nematodes can be mass-produced by in vivo or in vitro methods. G. mellonella is the most commonly used insect for in vivo mass production of EPN because it produces high nematode yields, is widely available commercially, and is very susceptible to infection.

Facilities and manpower available and the requirements for each option vary greatly, number of nematodes are required. In vivo culture is most appropriate for maintenance of colonies and production of lJs for lab and small-scale field tests. For large-scale production in vitro methods are practical. Which nematodes are needed, and length of storage before use. Steinernematids could be stored better than heterorhabditids. In vivo production of large numbers of heterorhabditids within a short enough time interval to avoid long storage periods may be difficult.

Nutritional composition: The nutritional composition of the medium is an important component in nematode production and could determine the final yield (Friedman 1990). Sub optimal composition presumably produces inferior bacteria that in turn result in poor quality nematodes reduced pathogenicity and low storage ability. The content and class of lipids in EPN can vary in amount and composition depending on culture conditions. Many studies of EPN behaviour and ecology over the past 10 years were originally undertaken to discover why these lethal insect parasites provided unpredictable field efficacy. Lab tests found a single species of EPN S. carpocapsae able to infect hundreds of species of insects. However field tests against many of these were disappointing, poorer than expected field results have been attributed to several aspects of behaviour and ecology which were understood at the time of application. Most research has focused on the IJs as this stage is applied by users to kill insects. IJs do not feed mate or go through development outside the host. Several EPN are currently under evaluation for mass production and field efficacy for biological control of insect pests. However quality and quantity of in vitro produced nematodes vary considerably depending on medium, temperature and production method. In addition nematode production should be cost effective. We investigated nematode yield, production time total lipid content and fatty acid composition of H. bacteriophora produced in artificial media supplemented with different lipid sources. Lipid source significantly affected lipid quantity and quality in H. bacteriophora. Media supplemented with expectable insect lipids produced yields 1.9 times higher than did beef fat or lard-supplemented media. Moreover the developmental rate in media supplemented host lipids was 1.7 times faster than that in media supplemented with beef fat or lard . Nematodes grown in media supplemented insect lipids accumulated significant lipid proportion per dry biomass than those grown in media supplemented with other lipid sources. H. bacteriophora produced in media supplemented with insect lipids, olive oil, or canola oil had similar fatty acid patterns with oleic acid (18:1) as the major lipid fatty acid. We recommend addition of fatty acid mixtures that resemble natural host lipids for mass producing EPN. This would provide nematode quality similar to in vivo produced nematodes and could improve yield.

Abstracts
1. Tangchitsomkid-N; Chinnasri-B; Nuchanart-Tangchitsomkid; Buncha-Chinnasri; Oates-CG. 1999. Mass rearing of Thai strain Steinernema sp. on lipid agar medium. (Editor). The 37th Kasetsart University Annual Conference, 3-5 February, 1999. 1999, 320-325; Text and Journal Publication Co, Ltd; Bangkok; Thailand
Tangchitsomkid and Chinnasri (1999) found lipid agar medium suitable for Steinernema sp.in Thailand at a temperature of 28°C. The possibility of mass rearing of a Thai strain of Steinernema sp. with its associated bacteria, Xenorhabdus sp., was investigated. The study was to determine nematode development, reproduction and final yields of infective juveniles on lipid agar medium at a temperature of 28&plusmin2°C. The IJs moulted to the fourth juveniles in two or three days. These J4 then further developed into adults which mated and gave rise to eggs and J1 inside the female body, this process took another two or three days. The J1 needed one to three days to develop into J2 and J3 (infective juveniles, IJs) which retained the cuticle of the J2 as a sheath. The production of nematodes by this method yielded 1.31 millions and cost 3.72 baht/one petridish (20g of the medium). This method is less expensive than the production using greater wax moth which costs eight times as much.

EPNs can be mass-produced by in vivo or in vitro methods. In the in vivo process, an insect serves as a bioreactor; in the in vitro process, artificial media are used. The in vivo process is very simple and requires only minimal initial investment. The equipment used is also simple: trays and shelves. The wax moth larvae are most commonly used to rear nematodes because of their commercial availability. The methods of nematode infection, inoculation, and harvesting have been previously described. Using the in vivo process, yields between 0.5 x 105 and 4 x 105 IJs/larva, depending on the nematode species, have been obtained. During the past few years, a distinct cottage industry has emerged that utilizes the in vivo process for nematode mass production for sale, especially in the home lawn and garden markets. However, the in vivo process lacks any economy of scale; the labor, equipment, and material (insect) costs increase as a linear function of production capacity. Perhaps even more important is the lack of improved quality while increasing scale. The in vivo nematode production is increasingly sensitive to biological variations and catastrophes as scale increases.

2. Buecher-EJ; Popiel-I. 1989. Liquid culture of the entomogenous nematode Steinernema feltiae with its bacterial symbiont. Journal-of-Nematology. 21:4, 500-504; 15 ref.
AB: Steinernema feltiae [Neoaplectana feltiae] strain 42, was reared in liquid culture along with its bacterial symbiont, Xenorhabdus nematophilus. First-stage juveniles developed into reproducing adults in a maintenance salts medium containing resuspended Xenorhabdus cells and the yeast Kluyveromyces marxianus or cholesterol. Cultures with media depths greater than 4 mm required aeration. Nematode populations increased as bacterial density increased. An optimal culture system was obtained when the bacteria and nematodes developed in a semi defined medium containing tryptic soya, yeast extract and cholesterol and were incubated on a rotary shaker at 25&plusmin1°C. Under these conditions, up to 86% of the final population were infective juveniles.

3. Zervos-S; Johnson-SC; Webster-JM. 1991. Effect of temperature and inoculum size on reproduction and development of Heterorhabditis heliothidis and Steinernema glaseri (Nematoda: Rhabditoidea) in Galleria mellonella. Canadian-Journal-of-Zoology. 69:5, 1261-1269; 26 ref.
AB: Larvae of G. mellonella were kept at temperatures of 5, 10, 15, 20, 25 and 30°C, and inoculated with 5, 10, 25, 50, 100 and 500 infective juveniles/larva of H. heliothidis and S. glaseri. Temperature and inoculum level significantly affected the time to first emergence, duration of emergence and yield of juveniles. All parameters, except emergence of H. heliothidis, showed significant interactions between temperature and the inoculum level. No juveniles emerged at 5 or 10°C and development time was most rapid at 25°C. No juvenile H. heliothidis emerged at 30°C or with 500 infective juveniles/host, but the duration of emergence was shortest at high temperatures with large inocula; yield per host and yield per inoculum were greatest at 20°C with small inocula. Yields of S. glaseri were half those of H. heliothidis; duration of emergence was shortest at low temperatures; yield per host was greatest at 20 and 25°C from large inocula and yield per inoculum level was greatest when the numbers inoculated were small (5-50/host).

4. Finnegan-MM; Chaerani; Downes-MJ; Griffin-CT; 1996. Yields and infectivity of a tropical steinernematid cultured in vivo and in vitro. 1995. Insect pathogens and insect parasitic nematodes. Proceedings of the first joint meeting. Bulletin-OILB-SROP. 19:9, 132-135; 6 ref.
AB: A strain of an undescribed species of Steinernema INA S14 was isolated in the Moluccas, Indonesia. This strain was cultured successfully in vivo in larvae of Galleria mellonella and Tenebrio molitor and in vitro in Bedding flasks, with an overall yield of 105 infective juveniles/g medium. Nematodes produced at 25°C in G. mellonella and flasks were more abundant but of lower infectivity than those produced at 30°C.

5. Noopur-Mathur; Mridula-Jain; Khera-S. Comparative infectivity and propagation of Steinernema feltiae and S. carpocapsae on Galleria mellonellalarvae. Journal-of-Parasitology-and-Applied-Animal-Biology. 1998, 7:1, 1-6; 8 ref.
AB: Comparative studies were made at 25°C under laboratory conditions on the infectivity and development of S. feltiae and S. carpocapsae on the last instar larvae of G. mellonella at dosage levels of 500 IJ/ml. S. feltiae was more virulent, being quickly attracted, efficiently invaded, and causing instant death of the host. It also propagated more rapidly and abundantly than S. carpocapsae.

6. Bedding-RA. 1984. Large scale production, storage and transport of the insect-parasitic nematodes Neoaplectana spp. and Heterorhabditis spp. Annals-of-Applied-Biology. 104:1, 117-120; 2 pl.; 11 ref.
AB: A method that was developed in Australia for producing up to 2000 million infective-stage larvae of the insect-parasitic nematode Steinernema bibionis (Neoaplectana bibionis) per 3-kg culture bag is described. The method is applicable to other species of Steinernema (Neoaplectana) and Heterorhabditis spp. The nematodes were cultured within autoclavable plastic bags, on crumbled polyether polyurethane sponge coated with chicken offal homogenate that had been sterilised and inoculated with the primary form of the appropriate symbiotic bacterium (Xenorhabdus spp.). Procedures for extracting and cleaning the nematodes on a large scale are described. Nematodes were stored and transported on clean sponge in aerated polyethylene tubes. The techniques are suitable for industrial use with little further development.

7. Vyas-RV; Pharindra-Yadav; Ghelani-YH; Chaudhary-RK; Patel-NB; Patel-DJ; Yadav-P. 2001. In vitro, mass production of native Steinernema sp. Annals-of-Plant-Protection-Sciences. 9:1, 77-80; 6 ref.
AB: In vitro mass production of native Steinernema sp. was attempted using 21 animal and plant protein based media. Maximum production of nematodes was recorded in hen-egg yolk medium which was economically better than universally used dog food biscuit agar. Production of the entomopathogenic nematode was poor in plant protein compared to animal protein based media.

8. Shapiro-DI; McCoy-CW. Effects of culture method and formulation on the virulence of Steinernema riobrave (Rhabditida: Steinernematidae) to Diaprepes abbreviatus (Coleoptera: Curculionidae). Journal-of-Nematology. 2000, 32: 3, 281-288; 31 ref.
AB: Using D. abbreviatus as the host, the efficacy of two commercial S. riobrave formulations, a liquid and a water-dispersible granule (WDG), were compared with each other and with in vivo produced S. riobrave. Nematodes in the commercial formulations were produced in vitro through liquid fermentation; the in vivo nematodes were cultured in Galleria mellonella and applied in aqueous suspension. Laboratory experiments measured nematode virulence in plastic cups containing soil and seventh-eighth instar D. abbreviatus. One laboratory experiment was conducted using only fresh nematodes (less than 5 days old); another experiment included WDG nematodes that were stored for 25 days at 10°C. Two field experiments were conducted in Florida, USA, in which nematodes were applied either to potted citrus (containing D. abbreviatus larvae) placed beneath mature citrus trees or to soil directly beneath the tree. In the latter experiment, efficacy was determined by measuring mortality of caged D. abbreviatus larvae that were buried beneath the soil surface prior to application. Mortality of D. abbreviatus treated with nematodes ranged from 80-98% and 50-75% in laboratory and field experiments, respectively. In all experiments, we did not detect any significant effects of culture method or formulation.

9. Finnegan-MM; Chaerani; Downes-MJ; Griffin-CT; 1996. Yields and infectivity of a tropical steinernematid cultured in vivo and in vitro. Insect pathogens and insect parasitic nematodes. Proceedings of the first joint meeting. Bulletin-OILB-SROP. 19:9, 132-135; 6 ref.
AB: A strain of an undescribed species of Steinernema INA S14 was isolated in the Moluccas, Indonesia. This strain was cultured successfully in vivo in larvae of Galleria mellonella and Tenebrio molitor and in vitro in Bedding flasks, with an overall yield of 105 infective juveniles/g medium. Nematodes produced at 25°C in G. mellonella and flasks were more abundant but of lower infectivity than those produced at 30°C.

10. Noopur-Mathur; Mridula-Jain; Khera-S. 1998. Comparative infectivity and propagation of Steinernema feltiae and S. carpocapsae on Galleria mellonella larvae. Journal-of-Parasitology-and-Applied-Animal-Biology. 7:1, 1-6; 8 ref.
AB: Comparative studies were made at 25°C under laboratory conditions on the infectivity and development of S. feltiae and S. carpocapsae on the last instar larvae of G. mellonella at dosage levels of 500 IJ/ml. S. feltiae was more virulent, being quickly attracted, efficiently invaded, and causing instant death of the host. It also propagated more rapidly and abundantly than S. carpocapsae.

11. Ogura-N; Haraguchi-N. 1994. Artificial media for xenic culture of Steinernema kushidai (Nematoda: Steinernematidae). Nematologica. 40:4, 613-616; 9 ref.
AB: Large numbers of S. kushidai can be obtained by propagation on an expensive artificial medium developed by Ogura & Haraguchi (1993). Other STEINERNEMATIDS and HRTERORHABDITIDS can be propagated cheaply on media composed of homogenates of offal or on media of inexpensive ingredients such as soya flour, corn oil, egg yolk, animal protein, nutrient broth and yeast cells. Attempts were made to substitute several of the ingredients of the Ogura & Haraguchi (1993) medium with these and other inexpensive materials.

GERMANY-MASS PRODUCTION
12. Han-RC; Ehlers-RU. 1998. Cultivation of axenic HETERORHABDITIS spp. dauer juveniles and their response to non-specific Photorhabdus luminescens food signals. Nematologica. 44:4, 425-435; 21 ref.
AB: A method is described for the production of bacteria-free H. bacteriophora and H. indica dauer juveniles by culturing these nematodes on P. luminescens symbionts isolated from H. megidis and from H. bacteriophora, respectively. The nematodes develop and reproduce, feeding on the bacterial cells, but the symbionts are not retained by the dauer juveniles. Through surface sterilisation of the resulting dauer juveniles, axenic dauer juveniles could be produced, which were used for compatibility tests. The tests showed that H. bacteriophora did not reproduce on the symbionts of H. indica and that H. indica did not reproduce on the symbiont isolated from an undescribed HETERORHABDITIS species (Q6). Dauer juveniles of HETERORHABDITIS species start development (recover) in response to food signals excreted into the culture by P. luminescens. The recovery inducing signal may be produced by strains on which the nematode cannot reproduce. In cultures of such incompatible bacterial strains, developing dauer juveniles take up the bacteria in the intestine but die after 3 days, probably because they lack the enzymes needed to digest the bacterial cells. Food signals produced by Xenorhabdus species, the symbionts of STEINERNEMA species, do not induce recovery of H. bacteriophora. Currently, bacteria isolated from different HETERORHABDITIS species are all assigned to the species P. luminescens. The specificity of the nutritive function supports the subdivision of the taxon P. luminescens into several species.